October 28, 2026
When Providers and Payers Disagree: What Self-Funded Employers Should Know
By: Brylee Trew
When a healthcare provider and payer disagree over reimbursement, who ultimately bears the cost? For self-funded employers, the answer is often their own health plan.
Although third-party administrators (TPAs) typically handle claims processing and payment disputes, self-funded employers are generally responsible for funding the claims. If a dispute results in additional reimbursement, those costs may ultimately come from the employer’s plan assets.
Healthcare reimbursement can be complicated, and even established processes for resolving payment disputes don’t eliminate the potential for additional costs. Understanding how these disputes are handled and how they affect plan spending is an important part of financial oversight for self-funded employers.
Why Providers and Payers Disagree About Reimbursement
The amount a healthcare provider bills for a service isn’t necessarily what the health plan will pay. The final payment depends on several factors, including the provider’s network status, contract terms, and applicable reimbursement rules.
For in-network services, negotiated contracts establish how providers will be paid. These agreements may use fixed rates, fee schedules, or other payment formulas. Even with a contract in place, disagreements can arise over how its terms are interpreted or applied to individual claims.
Out-of-network claims can be more complicated. Without a negotiated rate between the provider and the plan, reimbursement may depend on the health plan’s terms, applicable state or federal laws, and other payment methodologies. For certain out-of-network services, the No Surprises Act establishes rules for determining payment when providers and payers cannot agree.
Importantly, a reimbursement dispute doesn’t necessarily mean a claim was processed incorrectly. A provider may believe a higher payment is warranted, while the payer maintains that its calculation follows the applicable rules. Resolving that disagreement may require negotiation or, for eligible claims, independent dispute resolution.
How the No Surprises Act Handles Payment Disputes
The No Surprises Act, which took effect in 2022, protects patients from certain unexpected out-of-network medical bills. It also established the federal IDR process for eligible claims when providers and payers cannot agree on reimbursement.
Under the federal IDR process, providers and payers generally have 30 business days to negotiate a payment. If they cannot reach an agreement, either party may initiate arbitration. A certified independent entity reviews their offers and determines the payment amount.
In May 2026, federal regulators finalized changes to the IDR process to address delays, administrative costs, and communication problems. The rules lowered administrative fees to $15 per party per dispute and established new requirements for sharing claim information, documenting negotiations, and determining dispute eligibility. Several provisions will take effect as federal systems are updated.
These changes address concerns raised by both providers and payers. In an interview with Becker’s, TeamHealth Chief Medical Officer Dr. Jody Crane noted that providers may have limited visibility into how insurers calculate qualifying payment amounts, making reimbursement decisions difficult to evaluate.
Crane also cited industry research indicating that approximately 93% of out-of-network claims are resolved without IDR. Although most claims don’t require arbitration, disagreements that do reach IDR can involve additional fees, administrative work, and payment adjustments.
What Payment Disputes Mean for Self-Funded Employers
A payment dispute can increase what a self-funded health plan ultimately owes. Depending on the outcome, the plan may be responsible for additional reimbursement and administrative fees. For high-cost claims, these expenses can be significant. And because disputes may take time to resolve, the final cost of a claim may not be known until well after the initial payment.
Employers also need to know how their TPAs account for these payments. Are additional reimbursements reflected in claims data? Are dispute-related fees reported separately? Can the employer trace an adjustment back to the original claim?
The answers depend in part on the employer’s administrative agreement and the reporting provided by its TPA.
Employers should be able to see what was originally paid, what changed, and why. Without that information, they may have an incomplete picture of their healthcare spending. Independent claims audits are one way to address this.
Three Questions Employers Should Ask About Claims Reimbursement
Self-funded employers don’t need to manage individual payment disputes, but they should understand how their TPA handles them. These three questions can help employers assess their plan’s reimbursement practices and identify gaps in financial reporting.
- How are out-of-network reimbursement amounts determined?
Ask your TPA which payment methodologies it uses for out-of-network claims and how it applies the terms of your plan documents. Employers should also understand when federal or state payment rules apply and how reimbursement decisions are documented.
- How are payment disputes and adjustments reported?
Find out how your TPA tracks disputed claims, additional payments, and related administrative fees. Can you identify which claims were adjusted, how much additional reimbursement was paid, and why? Ask whether these costs appear in regular claims reports or require separate reporting.
- How do we verify that claims were paid correctly?
Even when a reimbursement dispute is resolved, employers need assurance that the final payment was calculated and recorded correctly. Independent claims audits can help verify that payments follow plan terms, applicable contracts, and reimbursement requirements. The U.S. Department of Labor’s guidance on fiduciary responsibilities also emphasizes the importance of monitoring service providers and the expenses paid by employee benefit plans.
Understanding the Full Cost of Healthcare Claims
Healthcare reimbursement doesn’t always end with the initial claims payment. Disputes, adjustments, and additional fees can change what a self-funded health plan ultimately pays.
Employers should expect their TPAs to provide clear reporting on these costs and explain how payment decisions are made. Independent claims audits can provide another layer of oversight. At Healthcare Horizons, we help self-funded employers verify payment accuracy and evaluate how their claims are administered.
Employers don’t need to be involved in every reimbursement dispute. But they should know what their health plan ultimately pays and why.
Get a clearer picture of your health plan spending. Talk to our team today
About Healthcare Horizons™
Healthcare Horizons is a healthcare audit and advisory firm dedicated to protecting the financial integrity of employee benefit plans. As a trusted partner to employers, brokers, and payers, we conduct independent healthcare claims audits to identify overpayments, uncover systemic errors, and confirm that plan administration aligns with contractual terms.
Our investigative, root-cause methodology reviews 100% of claims at the transaction level, combining advanced algorithms with deep human expertise to detect discrepancies that automated systems often miss. As a trusted partner and strategic extension of employers, we translate findings into practical recommendations that help organizations recover funds, prevent recurring issues, and strengthen plan performance.
